Showing posts with label narendra modi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label narendra modi. Show all posts

Sunday, September 11, 2016

WHAT IS GOOD FOR DEVELOPMENT IN INDIA—POLITICAL STABILITY OR POLITICAL COMPETITION?

Copyright@shravancharitymission


By Kamlesh Tripathi











   It is said, competition is good for consumers, but how about competition in politics? Where, I am reminded of what Indira Gandhi once said,   
  
    ‘My grandfather once told me that there were two kinds of people: those who do the work and those who take the credit. He told me to try to be in the first group; there was much less competition there.’

    She indeed was one of the tallest leaders of the Congress party, and even that of India, who could even dare to dismembered a neighbouring country. Therefore, if we superimpose her quote on the tenets of Congress Party or for that matter on any other political party it will be an interesting churning of inferences. 

    Before India attained freedom there were thirteen political parties that jointly fought the British Raj for independence, with Congress in the forefront. The focus then was not development, but to attain independence. Where, they competed and colluded in a smart manner and achieved it. Post independence some of these parties wound up as the mission was over, and some dissolved in each other. Congress then became the tallest party with practically no opposition. Muslim League the other powerful party was more or less hived off to Pakistan upon partition. Congress thereafter ruled for around fifty six years. But in these years they could have done much better than what they actually did. On the contrary they brought in the ‘License Raj’ post independence that only stifled the progress and development of the country and only benefited the few in power. So can one say political stability attracts development?

     License Raj was dissolved when P.V. Narasimha Rao in 1991 took over as the Prime Minister with Dr Manmohan Singh as his Finance Minister in a Congress Government. Thereon, things started looking up in India. But by then the coalition politics had also come into play. No single party was ruling the roost. Competition had set in, and every political party had to perform on economic parameters too, apart from the usual socialistic ones. The voter’s aspiration had also increased with the spread of literacy.

-          If we go through India’s GDP in absolute numbers we find in 1950-51 it was 2.79 lac crores that reached 20 lac crores in 1991-92 (15% annual growth for 40 years). But, was that enough when we were starting from a very low plank? This grew to 57.41 lac crores by 2013-14 (8.90% annual growth for 21 years). When the environment had become much more challenging. These growths were also facilitated by growth in population.

-         If we briefly analyse the annual growth of India’s GDP at factor cost again. In 40 years, starting 1951-52 to 1991-92. We will find. Thrice it showed negative growth, and in 79-80, after thirty years of independence it even went down to -5.2%, which is shameful. In fact growth started steadying above 5% only after 91-92 when competition amongst political parties had increased even within the coalition governments. And also when policies of open economy had set in.

-         In 1950-51 the food grain production was 50.83 million tonnes. In 1991-92 it reached 180 million tonnes. An increase of 129.47 million tonnes (an annual growth rate of 6.36%). This could have been much better, had the economy been opened in the 70’s, which the Congress government didn’t bother to do. By the year 2013-14 production reached 263.2 million tonnes. An increase of 83.2 million tonnes since 1992 (a 2.20% annual growth rate). That goes to show political competition lost focus on agriculture.

-         In the infrastructure sector. Construction of roads, (both surfaced and non-surfaced) picked up a steady pace only after 2008-09. After political competition started heating up in India and the same goes for exports which too picked up post 2003.

    The US is the world’s largest economy. There are two main parties, the Republicans and the Democrats. They follow each other close on heels on various issues. Yet, in the last two decades, like in the case of many other developed nations, its growth rate has been decreasing. If in the 50’s and 60’s the average growth rate was above 4 percent, in the 70’s and 80’s it dropped to 3 percent. In the last ten years, the average rate has been below 2 percent and since the second quarter of 2000 has never reached the 5 percent level. So has political stability in American politics helped the growth rate? Or is it that the continuing good sound policies of the government is driving growth, irrespective of which party rules, or is it that there is no politics over growth?

       In India we have seven national parties that include BJP, INC, CPI (Marxist), CPI India, BSP, TMC and the NSP. In addition we also have forty eight state parties. There is enough competition on the ground but whether it is helping development, is the big question. There is no firm paradigm of continuous fast track of development. That only goes to prove political competition may not mean development in India.

    So, sadly India has seen both the extremes. One, when Congress was stable and virtually in a monopoly for 56 years. When sadly there was only a steady, self complimenting and complacent development, and nothing exponential, which was what was required. And even now when you have a number of political parties on the ground, the development is dismal and that too at the cost of corruption that we saw in Congress UPA regime. Somehow, BJP has been able to reverse this trend because it is in full majority and politically stable, and its top leadership is averse to corruption. Needless, to say political parties are competing not for development, but for retention of power. This reflects glaringly in Uttar Pradesh.

    Uttar Pradesh the political hot seat of India has BJP, SP, BSP and Congress as main parties on the ground. In the past there were five prime ministers also who represented UP, apart from Dr Manmohan who also was under the command and control of the first family of Indian politics who also are supposedly from UP. Yet UP is where it was some forty years back. Despite, being the cradle of civilization, and the cynosure of every era. Today, UP is poor hungry, unemployed, illiterate and is one of the most prominent members of the Bimaru states of India.

    In six and a half decades of independence, India has grown manifold in population, but sparsely in infrastructure. But some states have grown faster than others and that’s where UP has lagged behind. UP is still way behind Kerala, Gujarat, Punjab and Haryana.

    So then what went wrong especially after independence and where did UP drop the ball? It was one of independent India’s most prosperous states. It kept growing till 1980s, from a steady growth in the beginning of the 1st five year plan in 1951 till the 1980s. UP has also seen frequent change of guard and therefore most certainly is a victim of political competition.

    So then what is good for India? Political stability or political competition? There are no straight answers, but I found an appropriate quote that can act as a solution—‘stop competing with others, start competing with yourself.

*****
   

Tuesday, January 12, 2016

Only a skilled nation can create national wealth

Copyright@shravancharitymission

By Kamlesh Tripathi






50% of the world’s wealth remains with 4-5 countries

    “National wealth” refers to the total value of wealth possessed by the citizens of a nation at a set point in time. That is, the total value of wealth and goods generated by all economic activity in a particular nation.

    It is also referred as the national (net) wealth, or the national net worth, or even the gross national wealth (GNW); summing up to the total national wealth and is the total sum value of wealth possessed by the citizens of a nation at a set point of time.

    This figure of national wealth is an important indicator of a nation’s ability to take on debt and sustain spending and is influenced by not only real estate prices, but also by the stock market, human resources, technological advancements which may create new assets or render other worthless, and it also steered by the national infrastructure and exchange rates. For value creation optimum skill levels are a must for any nation and therefore skill building is an important ingredient required to augment national wealth.

    The most significant component by far among most developed nations is commonly reported as household net wealth or worth, and also reflects infrastructure investment. National wealth can fluctuate, as evidenced in the US data (to follow) following the financial crisis of 2008 and subsequent recovery.

    There are 196 countries in the world today. If we compare the national wealth figures of the first 30 major countries we will come across an interesting paradigm as below:

    ANALYSIS

-               The world’s wealth has grown from 117,225 billion USD in 2000 to 171,577 in 2005, up to 216,374 in 2010 and to 250,145 in 2015. This is a cumulative growth of 113% over the last 15 years and an average annual growth rate of 7.5%.

-               USA remains the richest in terms of national wealth and also a consistent performer since 2000 to 2015. In 2000 it had a national wealth of 42,941 billion USD which has grown to 85,901 billion USD in 2015. This is a cumulative growth of 100% over 15 years and an average annual growth rate of 6.67%.

-           The national wealth of the US in 2000 was 42,941 billion USD, a little more than the national wealth of Japan, UK, Germany, Italy and China, put together.

-           The national wealth of the US in 2005 was 59,664 billion USD, a little more than the national wealth of Japan, UK, France, Italy and Germany, put together.

-           The national wealth of the US in 2010 declined from 59,664 billion USD by 4.27% to 57114 on account of the economic crisis, but it still remained more than the combined national wealth of countries such as Japan, China and France, put together. China by 2010 had become a major skill development country and thereby started generating wealth. It would not be wrong to say that 50% of the wealth of the world is controlled by only four or five countries.

-           By 2015 the national wealth of the US had increased to 85,901 billion USD, a little more than the combined wealth of four economic super powers such as China, Japan, UK, France and Germany.

-           China’s policy of underscoring on skill development under the banner of human resources gave encouraging results when its national wealth from 4664 billion USD in 2000 went up to 8674 in 2005 and to 17505 in 2010 and finally to 22817 in 2015. And from 6th position in 2000 it has jumped to 2nd position in 2015 in terms of national wealth.

-           India on the contrary from 14th position out of 196 countries in 2000 jumped marginally to 12th position in 2005 and to 11th position in 2010, but slumped back to 14th position in 2015. Its national wealth was 1163 billion USD in 2000, 2142 billion USD in 2005, 3788 billion USD in 2010, and 3447 billion USD in 2015. It has cumulatively grown by 196% with an average growth rate of 13%. But it is not enough when we compare it with world standards and our political establishment needs to understand this. India requires wide spread skill development if it wants to grow its national wealth. A lesson we need to learn from China where there is no opposition when it comes to policies affecting national wealth.

-           50% of the world’s wealth in the year 2000 was with super economic powers such as the USA, Japan and the UK. This changed somewhat in 2010 where 50% of the world’s wealth was held by the USA, Japan, UK and France, and this further changed in 2010 when 50% of the wealth of the world was held by USA, Japan, China (China replaced UK) and France. In 2015 the scenario further changed when China jumped to the second position next to the US leaving behind Japan to a close third.
-           Canada with 35 only million people has maintained a steady 8th position in the world. In 2000 it had a national wealth of 2,469 billion USD. This rose to 4277 in 2005, to 6212 in 2010 and finally to 6872 in 2015. Its cumulative growth in 15 years has been 178% with an average growth rate of 11.88%. But it has failed to take a quantum leap because it doesn’t have great reserve of skill bank which it is largely importing from other countries now. It also has a huge geographical territory and it remains to be seen how in times to come it will manage its assets with such a meagre population.

-           South Korea has turned into another industrial giant by lifting its skill levels. It rose from the 16th position where it had a national wealth of 1089 billion USD in 2000, to 2149 billion USD in 2005 at 11th position. But it slumped back to 14th position in 2010 even when it increased its national wealth to 2791 billion USD. But in 2015 it jumped to 12th spot with a national wealth of 3545 billion USD.
-           Greece a typical example with its economic crisis has crashed to the 30th spot in 2015 with 743 billion USD from the 23rd spot in 2000 with a national wealth of 493 billion USD.

-           Russia with the roots of once a super power has stagnated from 315 in 2000 to 1284  USD billion in 2015 but has gone up notches from 30th to 23rd position.
    The point to essence—mere size of population doesn’t increase national wealth. One has to individually create it for the nation. And you can create, only if you have the skill. The US remains the leader in this field with a population of 310 million people which is less than one third of the population of India. Even Canada with only 35 million people generates more revenue than India. Prime Minister Narendra Modi is by far on track by underscoring on skill development in India.
***






Thursday, July 2, 2015

COSTLY MISTAKES OF BJP

Copyright@kamleshsujata1

By Kamlesh Tripathi




P.M. NARENDRA MODI—from the voice of India, to silent mode.

India voted for Narendra Modi first, BJP second. For, in a short span of time he had become the voice of India even before he had won the elections for BJP. But his deafening silence this time in #Lalitgate will affect his image adversely. The way people remember his eloquent speeches, they will now remember his sting of silence signifying, as if he supported corruption. A very costly mistake. And, unfortunately for him, public memory is not short anymore, because of the media. He should therefore make a statement forthwith.

SUSHMA SWARAJ

By not resigning she is bringing her illustrious career to an end. As the first thing that will come to peoples mind when they think about her now on will be #Lalitgate and impropriety and nothing else. She has also ignored the subtle advice of L. K. Advani, the patriarch of BJP which is another mistake. And in this entire huff and puff she has helped no else, but the opposition. Such an experienced politician should have kept abreast with the golden adage, ‘a man is known by the company he keeps,’ and ignoring that she kept her friendship alive to the extent of impropriety, with Lalit Modi. And at this political hara-kiri one can only wish her the best.

VASUNDHARA RAJE

Too has committed a similar mistake of sticking to the chair. In future she and even her son will be remembered for serious controversies and which are perception wise even anti national. She again has handed over crores of votes to her rival party Congress, on a platter.

DEVENDRA FADNAVIS AND KIRAN RIJIJU


Where was the need to go and throw your weight around hapless air-passengers? Perhaps, the power has got into their heads. Before this incident people had a good and positive impression about these two young leaders of BJP. And what irritates the hapless public more is after bullying the airline, they even tell lies with equal temerity. This costly mistake of theirs people will never forget as they will be remembered as, ‘accha woh minister jo plane mein dadagiri karta tha.’ They can apologise even now, as they are young and have a long way to go.

SMRITI IRANI

She went, hammer and tongs against Rahul Gandhi. But she herself is caught in a degree row and she happens to be the HRD minister of the country. If she had some controversial degrees and certificates she could have stayed away from the Union Cabinet. BJP has come to power after a decade and with a huge mandate and the strategy of BJP should be to perform in a manner that makes others envious but on the contrary, what is coming to the fore is stupid controversies by some teeny-weeny BJP leaders.

PANKAJA MUNDE

Again with no idea about policies and procedures goes and orders stuff worth over 200 crores. And Devendra Fadnavis justifies it. With such leaders and ministers BJP doesn’t require any enemies as it is committing its own unplanned hara-kiri.

As a BJP supporter I would request Sri Narendra Modi to immediately to grip this turbulent ship hard, and bring it back to course.


****

Sunday, May 31, 2015

CROSSTALK: WHO HELPS WHOM … the X-factors of politics

Copyright@kamleshsujata1
By Kamlesh Tripathi

  
Dr Manmohan Singh after bitterly criticizing BJP in the morning calls on Prime Minister Narendra Modi in the afternoon. Many TV channels speculate as to why this meeting took place. There are rumours galore that he went to tutor the PM on how to run Indian economy, and some said he called on the Prime Minister for political asylum owing to various scams committed during UPA regime. And BJP won the general elections because of the scams.

On the face of it BJP and Congress might be bitter rivals but the moral of the story is even a bitter rival can give his opponent a lifetime of an opportunity. Perhaps, PM Narendra Modi didn’t forget this gesture. So who helps whom is often not in the hands of we human beings. 
***
 Mohd Asaduddin Owaisi, is a bitter rival of BJP. But what will happen if his party MIM decides to contest UP elections. The Muslim votes will further get divided amongst Congress, SP, MIM, BSP and BJP. And who will it benefit--BJP? So in politics no one knows who’s helping whom.

Sunday, May 24, 2015

MODI GOVERNMENT DOES WELL: Rent won’t allow longer stay in Lutyens’ zone now.

Copyright@kamleshsujata1

By Kamlesh Tripathi



Narendra Modi government has done extremely well by disallowing, Politicians and Bureaucrats to continue in their ‘Paradise’ (official Lutyens’ zone bungalows) when it’s a clear case of ‘Paradise-lost.’

Government truly is not a real estate agent and is not there to make money on such properties. By bringing about this order, BJP has hit at some politicians and bureaucrats where it hurts the most.

Recently TOI had covered shameless politicians like Ambika Soni and Kumari Selja of Congress party who were digging their heels for their sprawling bungalows, when they don’t deserve it anymore. Congress had converted Lutyens’ zone into a “Private Estate.”

Well done Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Mr Venkaiah Naidu!

Suggestion: The more you remove VVIP-ISM more you will stand a chance of returning in the next elections. Remember Indians are now frustrated with vulgar display of VVIP-ISM.

TOI: column 25.5.15 ‘Rent won’t allow longer stay in Lutyens’zone now.